The “Keeping Cow with Calf” project has brought attention to a humane and innovative approach in the dairy industry, focusing on maintaining the bond between mother and calf after birth. Led by SRUC and supported by the Scottish Government and the European Union through the SRDP Knowledge Transfer and Innovation Fund (KTIF), this initiative aims to evaluate and enhance the cow-with-calf dairying system. The project blends economic, environmental, and social research to support sustainable dairy farming practices in Scotland.

Key Objectives of the Project

  • Network Formation: A dedicated network has been established for stakeholders, including farmers, processors, researchers, and other dairy industry participants, who are interested in the cow-with-calf system.
  • First-Hand Insights from Farmers: Interviews were conducted with farmers who actively practice the cow-with-calf system. These interviews help gather practical insights into the benefits and challenges experienced by those implementing the model.
  • Sector-Wide Survey: Feedback from a diverse range of individuals across the dairy sector was collected to gain a broader understanding of perceptions and interest in the cow-with-calf system.
  • Farm-Level Economic Evaluation: Detailed economic studies were undertaken at the farm level to understand the impact of this system on calf growth rates, cow health, longevity, and overall herd performance.
  • System Benchmarking: Comparative benchmarking explored the system’s performance across four key dimensions: animal health, human wellbeing, environmental impact, and financial viability.
  • Business and Marketing Strategies: Marketing potential and processor views on cow-with-calf dairy products were analysed. This includes consumer demand, pricing, and distribution models.
  • Student Research Projects: Various student-led projects explored important themes such as maternal investment patterns and reasons for variation in milk yields over multiple lactations.
  • Prospectus Development: A comprehensive guidebook (prospectus) summarising the project findings was created to help farmers and other stakeholders evaluate the viability of converting to this innovative system.

Project Components and Focus Areas

Focus AreaKey Activities Undertaken
Stakeholder EngagementEstablishing a cross-sectoral network and conducting interactive interviews and surveys
Farmer ExperiencesDocumenting practical benefits and hurdles from existing practitioners
Economic AnalysisAssessing profitability, animal productivity, and cost dynamics of keeping calves with mothers
System Health BenchmarkingEvaluating performance using holistic metrics (human, animal, environmental, financial)
Product Market AssessmentExploring consumer demand and industry acceptance of milk from cow-with-calf farms
Student ContributionsIncorporating academic inquiry into maternal behaviour and lactation trends
Information DisseminationPublishing results and guidance in an accessible prospectus for the wider dairy community

Benefits of the Cow-with-Calf System

  • Improved Animal Welfare: Calves remain with their mothers longer, enhancing natural behaviour, social development, and stress reduction for both.
  • Positive Public Perception: Consumers increasingly favour ethical farming. This system aligns with the growing demand for compassionate and sustainable dairy practices.
  • Calf Health and Growth: Calves may experience improved early nutrition and immune function due to continued maternal milk feeding.
  • Cow Longevity: Improved maternal satisfaction and reduced stress may contribute to longer productive lifespans in dairy cows.
  • Diverse Business Models: Innovative marketing opportunities exist, including niche milk products marketed under ethical or animal-friendly labels.

Challenges Identified in the System

  • Lower Immediate Milk Yield for Sale: Retaining milk for the calf means less commercial yield, potentially impacting revenue unless compensated by price premiums.
  • Labour and Management Complexity: Additional management efforts are required for calf integration and cow-calf interaction monitoring.
  • Infrastructure Adjustments: Modifications to housing and milking facilities may be needed to accommodate calf presence and maintain hygiene standards.
  • Market Constraints: While consumer interest exists, processors may be slow to adapt, and consistent demand must be secured for sustainability.

Benchmarking the System: Human, Animal, Environmental, Financial

Benchmark AreaFindings & Observations
Human Health & WellbeingFarmers reported higher job satisfaction and emotional fulfilment when practising this humane system
Animal WelfareCows and calves display more natural behaviours and lower stress levels
Environmental ImpactSystems often tie into pasture-based or organic farming, supporting biodiversity and soil health
Financial PerformanceLong-term viability is possible when paired with premium pricing, direct sales, or brand differentiation

Contribution of the Dairy Research and Innovation Centre

  • Research Support: The Dairy Research and Innovation Centre at SRUC plays a key role in driving this and other research on sustainable dairy systems.
  • Innovation Hub: The centre offers a space where ideas are tested and results disseminated to farmers and the broader industry.
  • Cross-Project Integration: Learnings from other SRUC projects on feeding, breeding, and environment were used to enhance the cow-with-calf initiative.

Student Research Highlights

Project ThemeFindings
Maternal Investment PatternsIndividual cows show variation in how they care for calves; genetics and experience matter
Milk Yield VariationEarly lactation yields may dip, but long-term trends remain stable in healthy herd systems
Calf Behaviour StudiesCalves allowed to stay with mothers tend to be more socially adjusted and robust

Marketing and Consumer Insight

  • Ethical Branding: Products from cow-with-calf systems may carry ethical certification or animal welfare labels to capture niche markets.
  • Premium Product Strategy: Many consumers are willing to pay more for milk that supports humane animal treatment and ecological practices.
  • Processor Feedback: Processors noted that marketing support and consistent product availability would be key to scaling up distribution.

Future Directions

  • Policy Advocacy: Results from this project may be used to influence future agricultural policies favouring welfare-focused dairying.
  • Educational Outreach: Workshops, publications, and online resources are being developed to inform farmers, students, and consumers alike.
  • Expansion Potential: The model shows promise beyond Scotland and could inspire similar systems in other countries committed to ethical farming.

Future Implications

The “Keeping Cow with Calf” project has shown that innovation in dairy farming need not come at the cost of animal welfare. By studying this system in-depth across various domains—economic, environmental, and social—this project provides a roadmap for sustainable and ethical dairy production. Future growth depends on informed decision-making, strong marketing strategies, and continued knowledge-sharing across the sector.

Keeping Cow with Calf, A New Direction in Scottish Dairying

Cow-with-calf dairying is a transformative concept that challenges conventional dairy farming by allowing calves to remain with their mothers after ...
Avatar photo

Prachi

Research Impact and Global Influence of SRUC, A Detailed Overview

Research activity at SRUC (Scotland’s Rural College) extends far beyond academic boundaries, shaping communities, influencing policy, and solving real-world challenges ...
Avatar photo

Prachi

Postgraduate Research Opportunities at SRUC, A Comprehensive Guide

SRUC (Scotland’s Rural College) offers a unique blend of academic excellence and real-world application through its postgraduate research (PGR) opportunities. ...
Avatar photo

Prachi

SRUC Research Fellowships, Empowering Academic Excellence

Research fellowships serve as essential pillars in the academic world, enabling scholars to embark on ambitious projects, achieve independent research ...
Avatar photo

Prachi

Research Operations and Culture at SRUC, A Commitment to Ethical Innovation

SRUC (Scotland’s Rural College) builds its research foundation on ethical conduct, innovation, and sustainability. Research activities at SRUC cover diverse ...
Avatar photo

Prachi

Exploring Key Events at SRUC, Campus Open Days and Potatoes in Practice 2025

Events hosted by educational and research institutions provide valuable platforms for learning, networking, and hands-on experience. Scotland’s Rural College (SRUC) ...
Avatar photo

Prachi

Scotland’s Agricultural and Veterinary Higher Education Open Days 2025

A growing number of students are turning to agriculture, veterinary science, and environmental conservation as promising academic and career fields. ...
Avatar photo

Prachi

Scotland’s Rural College (SRUC), Nurturing a Sustainable Natural Economy

Scotland’s Rural College (SRUC) stands as a unique institution that merges education, research, and consultancy to develop and protect the ...
Avatar photo

Prachi

Scottish National Equestrian Centre (SNEC), A Hub for Equestrian Excellence and Education

The Scottish National Equestrian Centre (SNEC), operated by Scotland’s Rural College (SRUC), stands as a prestigious facility for equestrian sports, ...
Avatar photo

Prachi

Preparing to Study in Scotland, A Comprehensive Guide for International Students

Studying in Scotland offers much more than academic excellence. With its rich culture, friendly people, and scenic beauty, Scotland has ...
Avatar photo

Prachi

Training and Skills Development at SRUC, A Gateway to Land-Based Excellence

SRUC (Scotland’s Rural College) plays a vital role in enhancing the capabilities of individuals working in rural, agricultural, and land-based ...
Avatar photo

Prachi

Nationwide Study to Improve Poultry Welfare in the UK

A nationwide research initiative has been launched in the UK to enhance the welfare of commercial poultry during critical handling ...
Avatar photo

Prachi